Author: Devika R

April 7, 2026

14 min read

Most BIM projects on Gulf construction sites rely heavily on Navisworks clash detection. Catching a duct running through a structural beam in the model costs nothing to fix. Catching it on site after concrete is poured costs weeks and serious money.

Navisworks Manage helps identify these conflicts before they become site problems — and the BIM Coordinator handling clash detection plays a critical role in project coordination.

This guide walks you through exactly how clash detection works — from exporting your Revit models to generating a professional clash report — with the same workflow used on UAE and Qatar projects right now.


What Is Navisworks Manage?

Navisworks Manage is Autodesk’s project review and coordination software. Its core function is combining models from multiple disciplines — architecture, structure, MEP — into a single federated model, then running automated checks to find where those models conflict with each other.

That conflict-finding process is called clash detection, and the tool inside Navisworks that runs it is called Clash Detective. If you are evaluating coordination tools, see our Revizto vs Navisworks comparison for a side-by-side breakdown.

VersionClash Detective4D SimulationUse Case
Navisworks Freedom❌ No❌ NoView-only, free
Navisworks Simulate❌ No✅ Yes4D timeline only — no clash detection
Navisworks ManageYesYesFull coordination — what you need

Why Gulf Projects Mandate Clash Detection

On UAE, Qatar, and Saudi Arabia construction projects, the BIM Execution Plan (BEP) — the document that governs how BIM is delivered on a project — typically requires:

  • Weekly clash detection reports submitted to the BIM Manager
  • Zero unresolved hard clashes before the model is issued for construction
  • Documented resolution for every clash marked as “Reviewed” or “Approved”
This is not optional. Gulf employers expect engineers to open Navisworks, run a clash test, and produce a formatted report without being shown how. If you cannot demonstrate this in a technical interview, you will not get shortlisted for BIM coordination roles.

What You Need Before You Start

Prerequisites checklist:
  • Navisworks Manage installed (not Freedom or Simulate)
  • NWC files exported from each discipline’s Revit model — at minimum, one MEP model and one Structural model
  • Shared coordinates set up correctly in Revit, so models align when combined
Navisworks Manage interface showing Clash Detective panel for BIM coordination

The 8-Step Clash Detection Workflow

Step 01: Export Your Revit Models to NWC Format

NWC (Navisworks Cache) is the file format Navisworks uses. Unlike NWD files, NWC files stay live-linked to the Revit source — every time Revit re-exports, Navisworks picks up the latest version automatically. This is critical for active coordination when models are changing daily.

  1. Open the Revit discipline model (e.g., Revit MEP)
  2. Go to Add-Ins tab → External Tools → Navisworks 2026 (install the free exporter from Autodesk if not visible)
  3. In the export dialog, select Entire Project and format as NWC
  4. Name the file clearly: MEP_Floor3_Kochi_Hospital.nwc — Save to a shared coordination folder
  5. Repeat for every discipline: Architecture, Structure, MEP (and sub-disciplines if HVAC, Electrical, Plumbing are separate models)
FormatWhen to Use
NWCDuring active coordination. Live-linked, always shows the latest Revit export. Cannot be shared externally without Navisworks installed.
NWDFormal submissions, client reviews, or archiving a coordination snapshot. Standalone file — viewable with Navisworks Freedom.

Step 02: Create a Federated Model in Navisworks

Open Navisworks Manage. You are starting with an empty scene.

  1. Go to Home tab → click Append (not Open — Open replaces the scene; Append adds to it)
  2. Select your MEP NWC file → Open
  3. Click Append again → select the Structural NWC file
  4. Click Append again → select the Architectural NWC file
  5. All three models should now appear together in the viewport

Step 03: Set Up Clash Detective

Open Clash Detective: Home tab → Clash Detective, or use the keyboard shortcut Ctrl + Shift + C.

Click Add Test to create your first clash test. Rename it clearly — use a naming convention like MEP vs Structure or HVAC vs Structural Steel. You will see two selection panels: Selection A and Selection B.

Setting Selection A and Selection B:

  • Selection A → in the Selection Tree (left panel), expand your model hierarchy → tick the MEP model
  • Selection B → in the Selection Tree, tick the Structural model
Best practice: Use Selection Sets for recurring tests. Create named sets (e.g., “HVAC Ductwork”, “Electrical Cable Trays”, “Structural Steel”) and select those instead of entire models. This makes targeted retesting faster after model updates. For a deeper look at how disciplines interact, read Architectural vs Structural vs MEP: Understanding Building Systems.

Step 04: Configure Clash Settings

Before running, configure the clash type. Start with Hard. Fix all hard clashes first, then run Clearance checks with a tolerance appropriate to your project.

Clash TypeWhat It FindsWhen to Use
HardObjects that physically intersectPrimary coordination — use this first
Hard (Conservative)Same as Hard, but more sensitiveWhen you want to catch near-misses
ClearanceObjects within a specified distanceMaintenance access checks, insulation allowances
DuplicateIdentical geometry in the same locationQuality checks for duplicate elements

Step 05: Run the Clash Test

Click Run Test to run the selected test, or Run All to run all tests simultaneously. Navisworks processes the geometry of every element in Selection A against every element in Selection B. To understand how this step fits into a full project lifecycle, see How a Real BIM Project Works.

What to expect on a first run:

ScenarioExpected Clash Count
Raw first run, no prior coordination500 – 2,000+ clashes (do not panic)
First run after basic Revit coordination100 – 400 clashes
Target for issue-for-construction0 unresolved hard clashes
Navisworks clash test results showing new, active, and resolved clashes between MEP and structure

Step 06: Review and Manage Clash Results

After the test runs, the results list populates. Each row is one clash. Click any clash to zoom the viewport to that location and highlight the two clashing elements.

StatusWhat It MeansYour Action
NewJust found, not yet reviewedOpen it, assign to the responsible engineer
ActiveBeing worked on — resolution in progressTrack, follow up
ReviewedIntentionally accepted (e.g., acceptable software overlap)Document the reason clearly
ApprovedFormally signed off by the BIM ManagerNo further action
ResolvedFixed in the Revit modelRe-run and confirm resolution

Sort by Status: New first. Group by Assigned To if your team is working through them in parallel. Use the Comments field on each clash to write what the conflict is and what resolution has been agreed upon.

Step 07: Add Comments and Assign Clashes

For every unresolved clash, document three things:

  • Assignment: The name or discipline responsible
    Example: “MEP Team — Revit update required”
  • Comment: What the clash is and the agreed resolution
    Example: “HVAC duct running through 300mm structural beam. MEP to re-route above. Confirmed with structural engineer 04/04/26.”
  • Due Date: When the resolution should be completed

These comments are preserved in the clash report and form a coordination audit trail reviewed by project engineers and QA teams. This level of documentation is one of the top skills Gulf employers evaluate during interviews.

Step 08: Export the Clash Detection Report

The clash report is a formal project deliverable on BIM-mandated Gulf projects.

  1. In Clash Detective, click Report (bottom left of the panel)
  2. Format: HTML for a readable report you can email or share. XML for integration with project management systems. Viewpoint Report if you need screenshots embedded.
  3. Scope: Select Current Test to report on one test, or All Tests for a combined report
  4. Content to include: Status filter (New + Active + Reviewed), screenshots of each clash, assigned engineer name, and comments
  5. Click Write Report → choose your save location
What a professional clash report must contain:
  • Project name and date
  • Model versions referenced
  • Total clashes found / resolved / open
  • Status breakdown table
  • Individual clash listings with screenshots, assignments, and comments

Submit to the BIM Manager each coordination cycle (typically weekly). These reports also become a key part of your BIM placement portfolio.

Navisworks clash detection report export showing professional HTML report format

Clash Detection Best Practices for Gulf Projects

These are the practices that separate an engineer who ran Navisworks once from a BIM Coordinator that Gulf employers want to hire.

Run Tests on a Fixed Schedule

Weekly is standard on active coordination projects. Ad-hoc testing — when you feel like it — produces inconsistent coordination records.

Coordinate in Revit First, Then Clash in Navisworks

Before running Navisworks, do a visual check of your Revit MEP model against the linked structural model. Obvious route conflicts can be fixed in 20 minutes in Revit and will never appear in the Navisworks report. Save Navisworks for the conflicts you cannot see visually. If you work in Revit daily, keep these essential Revit shortcuts at hand.

Use Selection Sets for Targeted Tests

Instead of MEP (everything) vs Structure (everything), create tests like:

  • HVAC Ductwork vs Structural Steel
  • Electrical Cable Trays vs Structural Beams
  • Plumbing Mains vs Structure

Smaller, targeted tests run faster and produce more actionable results. Understanding the difference between MEP Design and MEP BIM helps you set up the right Selection Sets from the start.

Document Every Reviewed Clash with a Reason

Gulf project auditors will read your coordination record. A clash marked “Reviewed” with no comment creates a compliance problem. Always write why it was accepted.

Re-run After Every Model Update

A resolved clash in week 3 can reappear in week 4 if the structural engineer moved a beam or the MEP engineer revised a duct route. Re-run your full test suite after every discipline model update.

Version Your NWD Snapshots

At the end of each coordination cycle, save an NWD snapshot named with the date:

MEP_vs_Structure_Coordination_2026-04-06.nwd

This creates a coordination history if questions arise about what was resolved and when. Proper BIM data management makes this audit trail reliable.


Navisworks Shortcuts Every BIM Engineer Should Know

ShortcutAction
Ctrl + Shift + COpen Clash Detective
F4Toggle Selection Tree
F2Toggle Properties Panel
Ctrl + ASelect all visible elements
SpacebarToggle Walk navigation mode
Scroll WheelZoom in / out
Middle Mouse ButtonPan the view
Shift + Middle MouseOrbit (rotate) the view
Ctrl + ZUndo last selection action
HomeReset view to fit all

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between Navisworks Manage and Navisworks Simulate?

Navisworks Simulate includes 4D simulation (TimeLiner) and object animation, but does not have Clash Detective. Navisworks Manage includes everything in Simulate, plus full clash detection, clash reporting, and the Quantification module. For BIM coordination work on Gulf projects, you need Navisworks Manage. Simulation alone is not sufficient. See our top BIM software programs for a broader comparison.

Can I run clash detection without Revit models?

Yes. Navisworks Manage imports DWG, DGN, DXF, IFC, SKP, RVT, NWC, and many other formats. IFC is particularly important — it is the open BIM format used when disciplines are working in different software (e.g., architecture in ArchiCAD, structure in Tekla). Navisworks can federate and clash IFC models the same way it handles RVT exports. Learn more about cross-platform workflows in our OpenBIM case study.

How many clashes are normal on a first run?

On a medium-sized commercial building (8,000–15,000 sqm) with no prior coordination, 500–1,500 clashes on the first Navisworks run are common and expected. Do not be alarmed — a large first-run count just means coordination has not started yet. Well-run coordination processes typically close 80–90% of clashes within the first two or three weekly cycles.

Do Gulf employers specifically test Navisworks in interviews?

Yes — regularly. Technical interviews for BIM Coordinator and MEP BIM Engineer roles at UAE and Qatar firms often include a practical test: you are given a Navisworks file and asked to set up a clash test, run it, and explain the results. Employers at firms like Voltas, Drake & Scull, Al Shirawi, and GECO M&E are known to include such practical tests. Being able to demonstrate Clash Detective confidently — not just describe it — is what gets you hired.

Is Navisworks training included in BIM Cafe’s courses?

Yes. Navisworks clash detection and coordination workflows are core to both the Revit MEPF Master Course and the BIM Coordinator Professional Training at BIM Cafe. You train on real MEP project files — not tutorial exercises — and produce actual clash reports that go into your placement portfolio. BIM Cafe is an Autodesk Authorised Training Centre in Kochi, Kerala.

What is a federated model in Navisworks?

A federated model is the combined multi-discipline model you create in Navisworks by appending NWC files from each discipline (architecture, structure, MEP). The original Revit files remain separate — Navisworks references them rather than merging them. This means each discipline team can keep working on their own Revit model independently, and the federated model in Navisworks always reflects the latest version when NWC files are re-exported. For more on how disciplines coordinate, see Spatial Coordination with BIM.


Ready to Learn Navisworks Clash Detection the Right Way?

BIM Cafe Learning Hub in Kochi is Kerala’s Autodesk Authorised Training Centre.

Our Revit MEP and BIM Coordinator programmes include hands-on Navisworks training with portfolio-ready clash reports.

BIM Coordinator Training Revit MEPF Master Course